So, you’ve found yourself in the delightful position of having your insurance claim denied. Fantastic. Now you’re gearing up to appeal, and you’re thinking, “Hey, maybe I should ask for the credentials of the genius who made this decision.” Smart move. Let’s dive into why this matters and how to wield this information like a pro.

Why the Credentials Matter

Knowing the credentials of the person who denied your claim isn’t just about satisfying your curiosity. It’s about understanding the qualifications of the individual making decisions about your health and finances. Are they a medical professional? Do they have the expertise to determine what’s medically necessary for you? According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, when appealing a denial, it’s crucial to ask your healthcare provider to verify that the treatment or service provided was medically necessary and that the appropriate medical code was submitted to the insurer. 

Wait, an AI Denied My Claim?

That’s right. Some insurance companies are cutting costs by having artificial intelligence review claims. AI systems can process mountains of data and flag claims for denial faster than you can say “pre-authorization.” Sounds efficient, right? Except AI doesn’t have a medical degree or the emotional intelligence to understand why your treatment is necessary. It’s programmed to follow rules and cut corners wherever possible.

If you suspect an AI—or any automated process—was involved in your denial, here’s what to do:

1. Ask Directly: When you call your insurance company (yes, you have to call), ask whether a human or an automated system made the initial denial decision. If it was AI, demand a human review. Be firm.
2. Push for Transparency: If they claim a human reviewed the denial, ask for that person’s credentials. You have the right to know if the decision-maker has the appropriate qualifications to judge your medical needs.
3. Document Everything: Note down every detail: who you spoke to, when, and what they said. If you need to escalate the appeal, this will come in handy.

Or Was it an Actual Human?

If a real human made the decision, their credentials tell you whether they’re actually qualified to judge your claim. For example:

• If a doctor made the decision, are they a specialist in the relevant field?
• If it wasn’t a medical professional, why are they making medical decisions about your care?

If their expertise doesn’t check out, you’ll use that in your appeal to argue that the denial isn’t based on sound medical judgment.

Escalating the Appeal

Alright, so you’ve asked for credentials, pointed out any red flags, and submitted your appeal. What happens if the insurance company still says no? Time to take things to the next level with an external review.

An external review is handled by an independent third party. They’re not part of your insurance company, so their job is to look at the situation objectively. Here’s how to navigate it:

1. Request an External Review: Your insurance company is required to provide instructions on how to request this. Don’t let them “forget” to mention it—ask specifically.
2. Who Does the Review?: In many cases, the external review is managed by organizations like state insurance departments or independent review organizations (IROs). These reviewers are medical and insurance experts with no ties to your insurer.
3. Prepare Your Case: Include everything: your medical records, letters from your doctor, notes from your calls, and proof of the decision-maker’s questionable credentials (if applicable).
4. Meet the Deadline: External review requests usually have strict time limits. Don’t miss it, or you might lose your chance for an independent review.

Tips for Success

• Bring in Backup: If this feels overwhelming, reach out to your state insurance commissioner or an advocacy group. They can guide you through the appeal and review process.
• Know Your Rights: Federal law requires most insurance companies to offer an external review. If they’re acting shady, remind them that this isn’t optional.
• Persistence Pays Off: Insurance companies are banking on you giving up. Don’t. Many claims that are denied at first get approved during appeals, especially if you make it to the external review stage.

---

Final Thoughts

Look, fighting a denial can feel like a David vs. Goliath situation, but here’s the thing—you’ve got rocks. Whether you’re dealing with AI or a questionable “expert,” asking the right questions and demanding transparency puts the power back in your hands.

So, get on that phone, gather your evidence, and appeal like the fierce, capable human you are. And if they still won’t budge? Well, that’s why external reviews exist—to remind these companies that they don’t have the final say on your health.